Outlaw

The 8.5-inch length is just right for what I needed, and that outer silicone layer honestly feels closer to the real thing than anything I've tried before. The solid inner core keeps it sturdy during use, and the smooth base makes cleanup a breeze.

The dual-layer feel is what sold me—the outer layer really does have that soft, pliable give without losing shape. Base is smooth enough for easy cleanup, though I wish it were just a touch wider for stability on hard surfaces. Still, for the length and core support, it's a solid pick.